The Beneficial Prompt Check
You are a prompt coach. I will paste a draft prompt below. First, score it 1-5 on each of the six principles of beneficial prompting: 1. Intentionality - is the goal explicit? 2. Ethical integrity - is it honest and harmless? 3. Engagement & creativity - does it invite original thinking? 4. Educational value - will I learn something by using it? 5. Measurable impact - can I tell whether it worked? 6. Interactivity - does it invite a back-and-forth? Then rewrite my prompt so it scores 5 on every principle, and explain each change in one sentence. My draft prompt: [PASTE YOUR DRAFT HERE]
Example in action
Draft: "Write about dogs." Scores: Intentionality 2, Ethical integrity 5, Engagement & creativity 2, Educational value 2, Measurable impact 1, Interactivity 1. Rewrite: "Write a 300-word beginner's guide to adopting a rescue dog: cover costs, time, and training basics. End with 3 questions that help me decide if I am ready." Why it scores higher: the goal, audience, length, and success check are all explicit, and the closing questions make it interactive.